High earners recently spilled their secrets in the Canada Personal Finance subreddit. We trawled through the responses for you to tease out the best advice from Canadians earning $200,000 or more.
An interesting thing we noticed: the most useful replies weren’t about how much people earned. They were about the habits that help high earners keep more of it and worry less.
Before we dig into the tips, we wanted to say that Reddit posts can’t be verified. So, we went through the tips and pulled those that hold up even if the commenter is embellishing a little.
Without further ado, here are the top tips we found, each with one step you can take this month.
Key Takeaways
- A very high household income doesn’t mean more happiness. There’s value in finding things you enjoy that cost very little.
- Your time and money are limited – it’s worth considering the true costs of your decisions before you make them.
- Changes need to be realistic for them to stick. Make sure to think deeply about whether you can make a change before spending money on it.
You don’t need to spend a lot to enjoy yourself
The Reddit discussion centered around a user who was living frugally to retire early. Other users debated whether it was sad or smart to live so far below your means – but it exposed a story people tell themselves about money and enjoyment: you need to spend money to enjoy your life.
The argument from many users is that a walk in the woods is essentially free, and a reliable way to enjoy life more.
I’ll be the first to admit the outdoors can come with costs – you often need a car to get to nearby parks. Then you need appropriate shoes, a way to carry your water, the list goes on.
But, there are cost effective ways to do this if you’re organised and flexible. Don’t have a car? Car pool, bike, or take transit options. It’s less convenient, sure, but it’s also much cheaper. Don’t have a hiking backpack? Take whatever backpack you own and upgrade when you’ve saved up and can afford it.
The point remains: enjoying yourself doesn’t need to cost you hundreds of dollars. Nature is marvelous, and enjoying it doesn’t cost the world.
Swap recurring costs for one-time buys or less expensive options
One family built a home gym over two years, then used the money they had spent on gym memberships and classes to pay for their kids’ extracurriculars. Others use cheaper sub-brands of the big phone carriers (check out our partner PhoneBox to see if you can save on your phone bill – you probably can!) and drive paid-off cars until repairs stop making sense.
Here’s a list of swaps you might consider making:
Fitness and health
- Gym membership → home gym (adjustable dumbbells, a bench, resistance bands, a pull-up bar)
- Fitness class subscriptions → a used bike trainer, plus free workout videos
- Razor subscription → a safety razor (blades cost pennies each)
- Disposable menstrual products → a menstrual cup or period underwear
Home and utilities
- Furnace or water heater rental → buy your own (rentals are common in Ontario and often cost more over the long run)
- Modem rental from your internet provider → buy a compatible modem and router
- Home security monitoring → self-monitored cameras and sensors
- Professional lawn or snow service → buy the mower, snowblower or tools
- Carpet cleaning service → a carpet cleaning machine (or rent one as needed)
Food and kitchen
- Coffee shop habit → a good coffee maker or espresso machine
- Meal kit subscriptions → a slow cooker or pressure cooker and batch cooking
- Sparkling water → a soda maker
- Bread from the store → This no-knead recipe
- Fresh herbs → an indoor herb garden (bonus points to start from seeds)
Tech and entertainment
- Streaming services → rent movies from your local library and look into free streaming services like Pluto TV, CBC Gem, and Kanopy. Also, rotating one service at a time can cut monthly costs.
- Phone financing on a plan → buy the phone outright or used, then move to a cheaper plan (like PhoneBox)
- Software subscriptions → one-time licences or free alternatives
- Cloud storage → an external hard drive
- Music streaming → buy albums from artists you play constantly or listen to the radio with ads
- Audiobook subscription → your local library’s free apps (Libby, Hoopla)
Transportation
- Car lease → buy a reliable used car and keep it for years
- Parking pass → an e-bike or regular bike
- Car wash membership → a home wash kit
Kids and family
- Toy subscription boxes → a library toy-lending program or second-hand bundles
- Disposable diapers → cloth diapers
- Kids’ learning apps → used workbooks and library programs
Personal care and clothing
- Salon trims → good clippers for simple cuts at home
- Clothing rental or styling subscription → fewer, better-quality pieces
- Nail salon → a home gel kit
Pets
- Grooming appointments → clippers and a grooming kit
- Dog walker for routine walks → Wake up 30 minutes earlier, walk instead of watching tv, or swap dog walks with a nearby friend so your dog gets some social time plus more frequent walks
A few rules of thumb for these switches:
- Do the payback math: if the switch costs something (like the cost of clippers), divide the up-front cost by the monthly cost it replaces. That tells you how many months until you break even. Decide if you’re realistically going to make the switch at least that many times (ie. At least three haircuts to break even on clippers), then commit to it before spending the money.
- Consider borrowing before buying: libraries often lend tools, tech, museum passes and more, which can be cheaper than buying.
- Buy second-hand: Facebook Marketplace and Kijiji often have gym gear, bread makers and barely-used tools.
- Count maintenance and your time: a snowblower needs gas and upkeep, and cutting your own hair takes practice. If you can’t realistically manage the upkeep, consider which other swaps might be simpler and more sustainable.
Understand opportunity costs
An opportunity cost recognizes that putting limited resources, like time or money, towards one thing automatically means you can’t spend that resource on another alternative.
For example, an opportunity cost of watching your daughter play soccer is that you can’t work those same hours. Another example is buying a home, because you can’t invest the down payment in the stock market.
High earners in the thread weighed these trade-offs all the time. One couple rushed to pay off their mortgage and gained real peace of mind, but gave up the growth that money could have earned if invested. Another couple was urged to check whether the equity in their rental property would earn more elsewhere, with far less work. And one mother left a job paying about $122,000, trading income for time with her family. She found they’d been spending most of that extra income anyway.
The point is that opportunity costs aren’t bad – but they are important to understand and balance.
Do this: Before any major decision, such as buying a home, taking a new job or paying down debt, write two lists: what you gain and what you give up. Put a rough dollar amount or number of hours next to each item where you can. If what you’re giving up matters more to you than what you’re gaining, rethink the choice. If not, go ahead knowing exactly what it costs.
Pay yourself first, then spend without guilt
One parent described automatic monthly transfers into an RRSP, RESP, a TFSA, and a regular investment account. Once those go out, the family eats out and buys things for the kids without overanalyzing it.
The order is what matters: when savings leave on payday, whatever is left is safe to spend.
You can create systems like this that suit your financial circumstances, if you wish. I know we have in my house.
When I first met my partner, he had a car payment that he prioritized paying down quickly. Those debt payments came out first, on payday, so he didn’t skip them when other costs came up that month. So, this approach can work for debt payments as well as for saving and investing.
Give irregular costs their own accounts
The calmest posters in the thread treated big yearly costs like monthly bills. One couple keeps separate accounts for insurance, trips, home repairs, car upkeep, and a future truck purchase. I do this too and am a fan of this approach. I find that large costs are more manageable when they’re averaged out monthly instead of exploding one month’s budget.
Do this: List every cost that doesn’t arrive monthly. Divide each by 12 and move that amount automatically into its own savings account.
Yes, this includes travel.
The Reddit thread noted that things like vacations and repairs were what quietly pushed many over budget. One tip that I really liked from a poster was to have an annual budget for vacations – and determine where you go and how you travel based on that amount. In my experience, many people take a bit more of a YOLO approach when it comes to deciding whether to go on vacations or not, and how much to spend while you’re there.
A less exciting approach, but possibly a more financially savvy one, is to decide what you can afford first and then make the most of that budget. One Redditor observed “You could find a more wholesome family experience for half the cost. Hiking, camping, visiting smaller towns, avoiding tourist traps, travelling in low seasons, and travelling using travel points.”
A Big Takeaway: More Money Doesn’t Mean More Happiness
Many of the highest earners in the thread said spending more didn’t make them happier – some even said they would trade their current lifestyle for what they had at lower income levels.
The ones who felt secure had built a life they could keep up on less than they earned. One poster who retired at 50 said the biggest mistake he sees is building a lifestyle you can never afford to retire from. He then said: “My goal is just to say that constantly chasing an expensive lifestyle leaves many people unhappy and unfulfilled….at least, that has been my experience.”
Next Steps
There’s a lot of to-dos in this article, so we challenge you to pick one and actually do it. If you do, we’d love to hear from you.
Want breakdowns like this in your inbox? Join our email community. We regularly share information about immigration, money, and life in Canada – and we’d love to share those with you, for free. You can unsubscribe anytime.
This article is general information, not financial or tax advice. Talk to a qualified professional about your situation.
About the author
Stephanie Ford
Featured Stories
Canada Needs an Immigration Levels Plan People Can Actually Use
Read more
Canada Updates Job Bank Wages: 3 Ways This Could Affect Your Immigration Plans
Read more
IRCC Changes Express Entry Researchers Category: Teaching and Research Assistants Removed
Read more
High-Wage CRS Points Boosted Scores by an Average of 44 Points Among Community Respondents
Read more
-
Find the best immigration program for you
Take our free immigration quiz and we'll tell you the best immigration programs for you!
-
Get matched to job opportunities
Get matched to job opportunities from Canadian employers who are seeking to hire people with your skills.
-
Access our immigration roadmaps
Our immigration roadmaps will teach you the basics of Express Entry, study permits, and more! Take control of your own immigration process.
Unlock exclusive insights.
-
Find the best immigration program for you
Take our free immigration quiz and we'll tell you the best immigration programs for you!
-
Get matched to job opportunities
Get matched to job opportunities from Canadian employers who are seeking to hire people with your skills.
-
Access our immigration roadmaps
Our immigration roadmaps will teach you the basics of Express Entry, study permits, and more! Take control of your own immigration process.