“Openness, transparency and accountability are guiding principles of the Government of Canada”, it says so on the IRCC Transparency webpage.
If that’s the case, why is it so hard to understand how many people will become permanent residents in Canada in 2027, or how many have been admitted in 2026? Why do we need to look in multiple locations across multiple documents to get the full picture?
I’d argue (and I wouldn’t be the first) that the current Immigration Levels Plan for 2027-2029 falls short of those guiding principles.
Instead of just criticizing the government, I thought I’d put an idea out there for a better Immigration Levels Plan. So, if you gave me a magic wand, here’s what I’d change about the Immigration Levels Plan.
Criticisms of the Immigration Levels Plans for 2026 and 2027
Setting aside arguments about whether there’s too much or not the ‘right type’ of immigration planned, there are some very fair criticisms of the government’s formatting in recent Immigration Levels Plans.
The major criticism is that you can’t just look at the plan and know what permanent residence admissions will actually look like for 2026, or 2027. There are one-time initiatives planned, totaling hundreds of thousands of additional PR admissions, and very few details shared about what that means or how they’ll work.
These have paved the way for rumours of TR-PR pathways that don’t (and won’t) exist, and these rumours have very real, very harmful impacts on those already in Canada. I’ve heard more than once from people who see news about 100k extra spots, or 200k extra spots for people in Canada – and they think that pathways are just going to open up. While it’s the responsibility of those waiting in the queue to understand the immigration environment and make plans based on reality, confusing information from the government doesn’t help them.
A Better Immigration Levels Plan
Before I dig into the ‘how’, I wanted to explore what better means.
By better, I mean clearer and easier to understand. A better plan aligns with the government’s values of openness, transparency, and accountability. And it would be better if people could understand it without having to dig through different government documents to work out what’s going on.
Here’s what I would love to see in the immigration levels plans going forward:
Everything in One Table
This is the simplest ask on my list so I’ll start with it: one table.
I want to see every planned permanent resident admission for the year – the regular targets, the one-time initiatives, the time-limited measures, the lot – with a total at the bottom. If some of those numbers are ‘up to’ figures, label them that way. If some are spread across two years, say how they’re expected to split. Isn’t that why we have notional targets published in the Immigration Levels Plan after all?
Right now, working out the real total for 2027 means reading the plan, the supplementary information, the budget, and a handful of news releases, then doing the maths yourself. Immigration lawyers and consultants can do that (and do!). But a student in Brampton or a nurse on a work permit in Halifax shouldn’t have to.
An In-Canada Target and Outside Canada Quota
Immigration in Canada is discussed as a monolith – and I think this causes a lot of unnecessary confusion. I would hazard a guess that many Canadians would feel differently about 600,000 new people coming to Canada as permanent residents from abroad in 2027, compared to say, 200,000 – with the remaining 400,000 permanent resident ‘admissions’ being paperwork that moves temporary residents already living here to permanent resident status.
I personally feel that an in-Canada target and an outside Canada permanent residence quota could help to extinguish some of the fiery rhetoric around ‘immigration’ as a topic. It could quell people’s feelings about how ‘immigration’ could hypothetically stretch housing demand and jobs by challenging those feelings with facts. Maybe the government could even use those figures to inform housing starts, urban planning, and service development (but what do I know). In other words, couldn’t this turn ‘immigration’ from a bunch of numbers into an actual, well, plan?
Lastly, and importantly, it could help those who are already here on temporary status understand their true prospects of staying. Of course, those who have been living here temporarily have no guarantees of becoming permanent residents. But, I’d argue those who are coming on temporary status (especially as international students) and planning to spend years of their life and tens of thousands of dollars (if not more), these targets would be helpful. Imagine if they could easily compare the number of people who are here to the current and future plans for transitioning those to permanent residence, and then decide whether Canada is the right study destination for them. Of course, not all students want to stay, but that’s powerful information for those who do. It could go a long way towards repairing the damage international student changes have done to Canada’s reputation internationally.
Clear Allocations for French Targets
The government has committed to bringing in 9.5% of overall admissions in French, does that mean 9.5% of 380k or 580k? In 2027, unless I misunderstood the plans, it means 9.5% of the 380,000 admissions target will be French speaking.
But isn’t that a little bit misleading? The government is promising 9.5% of ‘overall’ PR admissions outside Quebec to meet their target. But, it’s not truly reflective of the actual potential level of admissions.
Additionally, it’s likely the government will later ‘celebrate’ meeting or exceeding its French targets for 2026 and presumably 2027. If it ends up admitting PRs in addition to the 380,000 planned admissions published in the Immigration Levels Plan, I may be cheering a little more quietly if the government celebrates hitting that 9.5% target.
Projections for Future Policies in the Notional Targets
One common criticism of the government’s current approach to immigration is that it seems very reactive. While I do think there’s a need for the immigration system to be agile in some respects, I do also think that predictability is important.
This year, the government added a separate target for the permanent Rural Community Immigration Program (after it was upgraded from Pilot Program status). Great – it’s helpful to see how many dedicated spots there are for that program.
I would have loved to see notional targets for programs that have been teased but not yet finalized. For instance, why not share information about what the promised H-1B program will look like targets wise in, say, 2027? We all know the notional targets for future years can change, so we’ll read it as an aspiration not a promise, but it would be helpful for so many planning their future to have more information about what may be in the pipeline.
My Wishlist for Future Immigration Levels Plans
While I’m here, I figured I may as well publish a wish list for the Immigration Levels Plans as well – because the answer is always no if you don’t ask.
Here’s what I would love to see in future immigration levels plans:
Retrospective Look to Last Year’s Targets
I would love to see a column added to both the permanent resident and temporary resident tables showing how the results compared to the published targets. I understand that they can’t share what happened in 2026 right now – because it’s November and they can still admit more people this year. But they can insert that information later and leave a placeholder when the plans are announced.
As I understand it, there’s no real backwards look where the government says this was our target and this is what happened. There are reports, of course, like the Annual Report to Parliament on Immigration. But, we just got the figures for 2025 earlier this month (yep, in November 2026). That’s not really a timely accounting of what happened last year, and what will change for 2026.
In the spirit of accountability, I think sharing that information in a space that makes sense to find it could be worthwhile.
Monetary Estimates of the Value of Immigration
This one might be a bit of a stretch, but hear me out.
So much of the conversation about immigration right now is about cost. What it costs in housing, in healthcare, and in pressure on public services.
The Immigration Levels Plas has been tied to the Budget being tabled in Parliament for the last two years. So why not start putting numbers on the value of immigration in the Budget too?
What if each plan was shared alongside a high-level estimate of what the planned admissions are expected to contribute? And yes – alongside that, the expected costs too, like settlement services and the infrastructure needed to support population growth.
I know estimates like these are never perfect, and I know they’d be picked apart from all sides (that’s sort of the point). But putting a number on it would move the conversation from ‘immigration is good’ vs ‘immigration is bad’ to something a lot more useful: is this plan worth what it costs, and how could it be better?
Make The Immigration Levels Plan a Plan People Can Use
I’ll be the first to admit that none of this is easy. Immigration planning involves provinces, Quebec’s separate system, processing capacity, and a political climate that’s changing over time. I don’t envy the people at IRCC who put these plans together.
But “openness, transparency and accountability” isn’t my standard: it’s the government’s standard for itself. And a plan that needs a spreadsheet, three documents, and at least one news site to understand doesn’t quite live up to those guiding values.
So, consider this my rallying cry, for a plan that both regular folks and those in charge can use.
Stay Informed—Sign Up Now!
Looking for Express Entry updates but fed up with scouring the internet? Now you can get the latest Express Entry news and expert insight delivered to your inbox.
About the author
Stephanie Ford
Featured Stories
Canada Updates Job Bank Wages: 3 Ways This Could Affect Your Immigration Plans
Read more
IRCC Changes Express Entry Researchers Category: Teaching and Research Assistants Removed
Read more
High-Wage CRS Points Boosted Scores by an Average of 44 Points Among Community Respondents
Read more
Canadian Citizenship Test: How It Works and How to Pass
Read more
-
Find the best immigration program for you
Take our free immigration quiz and we'll tell you the best immigration programs for you!
-
Get matched to job opportunities
Get matched to job opportunities from Canadian employers who are seeking to hire people with your skills.
-
Access our immigration roadmaps
Our immigration roadmaps will teach you the basics of Express Entry, study permits, and more! Take control of your own immigration process.
Unlock exclusive insights.
-
Find the best immigration program for you
Take our free immigration quiz and we'll tell you the best immigration programs for you!
-
Get matched to job opportunities
Get matched to job opportunities from Canadian employers who are seeking to hire people with your skills.
-
Access our immigration roadmaps
Our immigration roadmaps will teach you the basics of Express Entry, study permits, and more! Take control of your own immigration process.